Factoring is a popular financial tool, especially in industries like construction. It offers quick access to cash while waiting for client payments. However, the decision between recourse factoring and non-recourse factoring is crucial for construction company owners. Understanding the difference is essential for choosing the option that best fits your business’s unique needs.
Before We Begin, Let’s Define Factoring
Factoring is a financial product where a factoring company buys unpaid invoices from a businesses. The exchange is a great option for quick infusions of working capital. For companies that face long payment cycles like trucking or construction, factoring can bridge cash flow gaps. This will help the business meet payroll, purchase needed materials, and start new projects on time.
IN DEPTH READING: Everything You Need to Know about Invoice Factoring
It is helpful to understand that not all factoring agreements are the same. There is a significant distinction between recourse and non-recourse factoring.
What is Recourse Factoring?
Recourse factoring is the most common type of factoring. In this option, if a client fails to pay, your business is responsible for repayment.
Key Benefits of Recourse Factoring:
- Lower fees: Because your business holds some of the risk, your fees can be. This can be beneficial for construction companies operating on tight margins.
- Faster approvals: Since the factoring company assumes less risk, the approval process for recourse factoring can be quicker, leading to faster funding.
- More flexibility: Once a client is approved, construction businesses gain the flexibility to sell invoices on a rolling basis, enhancing cash flow management as projects progress. And with prior approval, the business can take advantage of spot factoring — the ability to strategically choose a single, select invoice for focused funding.
Potential Drawbacks of Recourse Factoring:
- Risk of repayment: As mentioned before, if a client defaults, your business is responsible for paying the factoring company. This can be a concern if you’re working with clients who have a history of slow payments.
- Credit risk: Your business assumes the credit risk of your clients. If they are not financially stable this could ultimately expose your company to the repayment. Keep in mind, factoring’s thorough due diligence process should uncover any credit issues in advance minimizing surprises.
What is Non-Recourse Factoring?
In non-recourse factoring, the factoring company assumes the risk of non-payment. If your client defaults on an invoice, your business is not liable for repaying it. This arrangement may sound more appealing to construction companies, the primary detractor are the higher costs.
Key Benefits of Non-Recourse Factoring:
- Less risk: Non-recourse factoring protects your business from client insolvency. This can be reassuring when dealing with higher-risk clients.
- Credit protection: Since the factoring company assumes the credit risk, bad debts are no longer your problem. This allows you to focus on ongoing projects without worrying about client reliability.
Potential Drawbacks of Non-Recourse Factoring:
- Higher fees: Non-recourse factoring typically comes with higher fees because the factoring company assumes greater risk. For businesses with tight margins, these costs need to be considered.
- Stricter due diligence: Not all invoices qualify for non-recourse factoring. Factoring companies typically impose much stricter credit checks on both you and your clients, limiting your options.
Recourse vs Non-Recourse Factoring in Construction — The Pros and Cons List
For construction business owners, both options come with distinct advantages and drawbacks. The choice between recourse and non-recourse factoring largely depends on the stability of your clients, your company’s risk tolerance, and the cost structure you’re willing to manage.
| Recourse Factoring | Non-Recourse Factoring |
|---|---|
| Pros | Pros |
| Lower factoring fees due to shared risk | Protection from client insolvency |
| Faster approval and access to working capital | Credit risk is transferred to the factoring company |
| More invoice flexibility | Increased peace of mind in unstable economic environments |
| Cons | Cons |
| Risk of repayment of invoices if clients default | Higher costs associated with the added protection |
| Retains credit risk exposure to potentially unstable clients | Stricter client eligibility criteria for factoring invoices |
Examples of Factoring for the Construction Industry
Construction businesses face unique challenges, including lengthy payment cycles and the constant need for working capital. Recourse factoring can be a strategic way to manage cash flow, especially when working with reliable clients. For example, a client of ours, a finishing contractor, recently used a $1.25 million recourse factoring facility to cover payroll while waiting for client payment. This allowed them to continue work on other projects without interruption.
However, if you’re wanting to factor invoices from clients that may pose a higher credit risk, non-recourse factoring might be a better option. A residential roofing contractor, for instance, wanting to factor the invoices of a customer with questionable financial history, may look to non-recourse factoring to try to protect their business from their issues.
How to Choose Between the Two
To determine whether recourse or non-recourse factoring is the better fit for your construction business, consider the following:
- Your Client’s Stability: If you work with long-term, reliable clients who typically pay on time, recourse factoring offers lower costs without risk exposure.
- Your Cost Sensitivity: For companies with tight profit margins, the lower fees of recourse factoring may be preferable. Non-recourse factoring’s higher costs could outweigh the benefits, especially when margins are slim.
- Your Risk Tolerance: Non-recourse factoring is best suited for businesses that have not choice but to avoid the risks associated with client defaults. These may be ones with newer or higher-risk clients.
How Do I Know if the Factoring Company is Recourse or Non-recourse?
There are a few ways to know if the factoring company offers recourse or non-recourse factoring. Because non-recourse’s lower risk is easier to market they will usually promote it on their website. If you do not see the term, their factoring is more than likely recourse.
But the easiest way to know is simply by asking them during your intro call.
Is Non-Recourse Factoring Worth the Higher Cost?
Yes, non-recourse factoring may seem like a safer option, the higher fees can significantly impact your bottom line, especially if you’re working with multiple projects that require continuous funding. In many cases, recourse factoring provides plenty of security, especially in the commercial construction, while still offering a cost-effective solution for improving cash flow.
Next Steps
Both recourse and non-recourse factoring are valuable financial tools for construction businesses, helping them maintain liquidity and take on new projects without waiting for client payments. While non-recourse factoring offers greater protection from bad debt, its higher costs may not always be justified. On the other hand, recourse factoring provides a more affordable and flexible option for companies with reliable clients.
Understanding the difference — recourse vs non-recourse factoring allows you to pick the best for your company. If you have questions about how factoring can work in your unique business, give us a call. We can help walk you through the details.
Back to blog